Does Japan's Semiconductor Industry Have a Future

Advertisements

  • February 11, 2025

Stepping into Akihabara, a well-known district in Tokyo celebrated for its electronics and otaku culture, one might notice a striking normalization in the products available on the shelves of the electronics megastoreIt has become increasingly difficult to find a diverse array of USB drives or solid-state drives (SSDs) except, prominently, for the red "KIOXIA" brandThe unmistakable decline in product variety highlights the broader narrative of Japan's diminishing semiconductor industry, where familiar brands have become a rarity, signaling not only limited sales but also the precarious situation faced by manufacturers attempting to navigate this changing economic landscape.

KIOXIA, once a part of Toshiba's semiconductor division, is a prime example of this struggleFollowing significant losses related to its investments in nuclear power, Toshiba was compelled to carve out its most profitable segment—the semiconductor division—to recuperate its financial footing

This strategic move led to KIOXIA being established as an independent company on June 16, 2017, though several attempts at an initial public offering (IPO) have notably been unsuccessful until now.

Looking ahead to December 18, 2024, there is cautious optimism among investors about KIOXIA's potential to finally achieve a successful IPOHowever, the expected financial yield from this public offering remains modest at bestDespite the Japanese government's substantial support for the semiconductor industry, as well as various policy incentives and financial backing for KIOXIA, the company finds itself grappling with obstacles faced by numerous firms in the sector, revealing the multifaceted challenges within Japan's semiconductor ecosystem.

The principal impediment confronting KIOXIA stems from the Japanese semiconductor industry’s decline over the past two to three decades

Efforts to revitalize the sector through economic security policies that aim to decouple from the Chinese market have, for many, raised doubts about the feasibility of such a planInvestors increasingly voice concerns that proceeding with heightened economic security measures may only hasten the obsolescence of Japan's semiconductor industry.

Japanese investors are skeptical that KIOXIA's upcoming IPO could remedy the industry's stagnationThe persistent emphasis on economic decoupling from China exacerbates the crisis of market viability for Japanese chipmakers, which leads to a troubling prophecy for the country’s semiconductor future.

On a related note, the Tokyo Stock Exchange underwent restructuring in April 2022, introducing three primary market segments: the Prime Market, the Standard Market, and the Growth Market

KIOXIA intends to list on the Prime Market, but the implications of this choice resonate throughout multiple layers of Japan's economyThe terminology and expectations surrounding this prime designation may suggest profitability and growth; however, the reality often reveals a far more complex and risk-laden environment for sorts of companies—the so-called "prime" market frequently disguises intrinsic uncertainties.

The risks associated with KIOXIA are particularly notable due to several consecutive years of losses, compounded by minimal profitabilityUnlike other nations, Japan lacks substantial mobile phone and electric vehicle sectors and has yet to foster globally impactful IT platforms or enterprises within the realm of artificial intelligenceConsequently, the market for semiconductors remains restricted, further stymied by firms scaling back on research and development while the government increasingly cuts education funding.

Signs of KIOXIA’s impending challenges can be discerned in its dismal sales figures

alefox

During a five-year span from 2019 to 2023, KIOXIA peaked in revenue in 2021 with a whopping ¥1.5265 trillion (approximately $7.23 billion), only to plummet to ¥1.0766 trillion ($510 million) by 2023—a decline resembling return to pre-2019 stabilityAdditionally, losses manifested starkly for the same period, with operating losses soaring to ¥246.4 billion ($11.7 million) and net losses approaching ¥237.4 billion ($11.3 million).

The company’s weak financial performance directly impacts its share price following public listing, with KIOXIA projecting an offering price of ¥1,455 per share, thus estimating a market capitalization of around ¥780 billion (approximately $3.7 billion). Disturbingly, this figure falls dramatically short of the ¥2 trillion ($948 million) target initially envisioned!

Historically, when KIOXIA separated from Toshiba, the deal included transferring ownership for a staggering ¥2 trillion from its acquisition by a consortium led by Bain Capital

After the acquisition, Toshiba reinvested approximately ¥350.5 billion (around $1.15 billion) back into KIOXIA, relinquishing KIOXIA into a web of corporate affiliations.

However, analyzing the financial maneuvers unveils alarming discrepanciesOf the ¥2 trillion deal, half was designated for buyer's equity and the other half financed through loans and preferred stocksKIOXIA now finds itself in a precarious position—needing to achieve at least ¥1 trillion in market capitalization upon IPO, merely for the acquisition to break even.

Given financing statements highlighting current debts of approximately ¥1.1113 trillion (around $540 million) alongside a meager self-capital ratio of 15.7 percent, the imminent reception of KIOXIA's IPO has become increasingly tenuous, raising fundamental questions on the soundness of its market entrance.

The aftermath of this financial rollercoaster spells further trouble for Toshiba, which finds itself strapped for avenues to rejuvenate post-nuclear crises

With KIOXIA's downfall, Toshiba's path to recovery remains obscured under a dark cloud of uncertainty regarding the semiconductor industry.

Amidst this uncertainty, the under-construction semiconductor enterprise Lapridase faces pressing demands as it attempts to regroup as part of Japan's semiconductor renaissance strategyHowever, the outlook for Japan's semiconductor sector remains dim.

Despite the previous administration’s rhetoric of adopting a combative stance against China, signaling a disconnection between economic ecosystems, a recent shift has invoked nuances within the Sino-Japanese economic relationshipNevertheless, the pressures towards economic security and decoupling have persisted, unabated.

Under the administration of Yoshihide Suga, calls for detaching from China had been fervent, especially within the semiconductor field to carve out Japanese dominance amidst international competition

The cabinet that succeeded it, under Secretary-General Shigeru Ishiba, showcased a willingness to adapt its financial strategies—projecting fiscal support exceeding ¥10 trillion (around $47.4 billion) towards semiconductor and AI technology development amidst an already strained national budget, suggesting an unwavering determination to bolster the semiconductor sector.

Despite significant budgeting efforts, investments in semiconductor development continue to remain insufficientThis government seeks capital flows via national bonds to facilitate subsidies for semiconductor companies like LapridaseInitial reports dated November 28 indicate that the government allocated ¥920 billion (approximately $448 million) to Lapridase, anticipating additional funding surpassing ¥4 trillion (around $1.95 billion) before the project officially transitions to mass production in 2027.

A former parliament member remarked on this unprecedented move, saying, “Japan has long relied on public-private partnerships in establishing enterprises, yet this heavy reliance on public funds for semiconductor endeavors reflects a marked departure from capitalist norms and carries substantial risk.”

KIOXIA, which finds itself wedged between fulfilling consumer demand for USB drives and SSDs and maneuvering within the complexities of sustaining research and development while battling stringent financial constraints, continues to struggle amidst these challenging dynamics.

Consumer electronics, including USB drives, have weighed heavily on sales projections, while the nation's relatively stagnant mobile and electric vehicle markets further complicate the semiconductor landscape

Moving beyond consumer trends, it seems likely that sectors like autonomous driving and high-end chip demand may remain in the shadows for the foreseeable future.

The shrinking economic landscape complicates sales figures for reasonably priced items like USB drives, let alone high-end chips perceived as luxury commoditiesJapan’s economic security approach, coupled with a deliberate severing of ties with the Chinese market, only serves to deepen these concerns, creating a rather bleak future for its semiconductor industry.

In light of KIOXIA's daunting prospects, reflections on the evolving dynamic between Japan's semiconductor industry and companies like Lapridase point towards a reality where Japan’s innovation potential could further diminish amid significant resource constraints and market pressures.

Comments (15 Comments)

Leave A Comment